Real example · BotView · checked September 8 and October 12, 2026
Does ChatGPT recommend BotView?
It’s the question every business owner is asking about their own company, so we asked it about ours. Short answer: rarely, and only when a page the answer reads already lists us.
Five questions, each run twice using OpenAI with web search, the same check BotView Pro runs. First on September 8, then again five weeks later with the questions unchanged. These are selected answers, not consumer ChatGPT rankings.
Was BotView named?
| Question | Sep 8 | Oct 12 |
|---|---|---|
| Affordable AEO/GEO tools for a UK small businessDoesn’t name BotView | 0 of 2 | 2 of 2 |
| AI visibility tools under $50/monthDoesn’t name BotView | 0 of 2 | 0 of 2 |
| Free tools that check AI crawler accessDoesn’t name BotView | 0 of 2 | 0 of 2 |
| What does BotView offer?Names BotView | 2 of 2 | 2 of 2 |
| BotView vs OtterlyAINames BotView | 2 of 2 | 2 of 2 |
The discovery questions are the ones that matter: a customer asking for tools without knowing our name. Asked by name, AI found us every time.
Why not? Look at what the answer read
Each answer runs a web search and builds its recommendations from the pages it finds. The cited sources explain more than anything else we checked.
- It recommends whoever its sources list
- For “tools under $50/month”, every suggestion (Otterly AI, RankScale, Airefs, Robot Visible, AthenaHQ) came from two third-party roundups: robotvisible.com and getairefs.com. Neither page mentioned BotView when we checked on October 12. If the pages it reads don’t name you, the answer won’t either.
- It cites pages built for the exact question
- For “free tools that check AI crawler access”, both runs cited the same seven checker homepages, each a page whose whole purpose is that question. We have free checker pages too; they weren’t in the results that search returned. We can see what was cited, not why the search chose it.
- Where we did appear, our own page was the source
- BotView went from absent to named in both “affordable AEO/GEO tools” answers. Where the answer linked a source for us, it was our own comparison of affordable tools, published September 8 with prices for six products. That isn’t an independent recommendation, but it shows a plain comparison page with real prices can become the source a month later.
- Old facts linger
- All four answers to the questions naming us said the Free plan has 3 scans a month. It has been 20 since September 23, and three of those answers cited the pricing page that says so. Fixing your site is the first step; answers can take weeks to catch up.
- Crawler access wasn’t the problem
- Our robots.txt allows OpenAI’s search crawler (OAI-SearchBot) and our pages load for it. If your site blocks it or hides content behind JavaScript, fix that first: a free scan checks both.
If ChatGPT doesn’t recommend your company
- Ask what your customers ask, without your name. Note who is named instead.
- Open the cited sources. Those pages are what the answer was built from.
- Get onto those pages, or publish the page that answers the question. For us that means asking roundup authors to include BotView and keeping our own comparison pages accurate.
- Make sure crawlers can read your site. Blocked or JavaScript-only content can’t be cited.
- Check again in a few weeks. Two runs on one day aren’t a trend; ours changed over five weeks.
This is what our evidence points to, not a proven ranking formula. We haven’t measured how much each step changes the answers.
Does ChatGPT recommend your business?
Ask the questions your customers ask. See whether you’re named, who appears instead and which sources the answers used, then decide what to fix.
Analyze my business · $9/month →20 AI checks + 50 crawler scans monthly. A five-question analysis uses 5 checks. USD · Cancel anytime.
BotView self-assessment using selected OpenAI API answers, not consumer ChatGPT rankings. AI claims can be wrong; verify the sources. Full answers and review notes are below.
October 12: all 10 answers, sources and review notes
The same five questions as September, unchanged. Questions were written by us, not taken from measured customer query volume. All ten outputs are preserved, including mistakes. Source links are supplied by the model, not endorsements.
1. Which affordable AEO or GEO tools should a UK small business consider for reviewing its website and checking AI answers? Compare entry prices, included checks and limitations.Discovery — does not name BotView · two runs
Run 1
Review note: BotView is named and cited, but the source is our own comparison page (/affordable-aeo-geo-tools), not an independent recommendation. Several links are unrelated to the claim next to them (a German fire-safety downloads page, Beamcraze, Kieft & Sons, rockcheck.blog). The free-plan line is current. Other vendor prices are not verified here.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
- Downloads zu unseren Produkten | Hekatron Brandschutz
- Affordable AEO & GEO Tools Up to $50/Month (2026) | BotView
- Beamcraze
- Affordable AEO & GEO Tools Up to $50/Month (2026) | BotView
- 8 Best Cognizo AI Alternatives Built for AI Search (2026)
- Best AEO & GEO Tools (2026): 5 Options Compared | BotView
- 9 Formas de Medir tu Visibilidad en Perplexity, ChatGPT y Gemini con HubSpot
- RockCheck — Tested GEO & AEO Tools for Small Agencies
- Kieft & Sons Ltd
- Pricing: £99/month, expert from £1,495 | AEOscore UK
Run 2
Review note: BotView is named with correct Pro details, but no botview.app link survived in this run, so the match is marked uncertain. The same unrelated links appear as in run 1. Other vendor prices are not verified here.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
A matching name appears, but the answer does not clearly identify your business. Review the original evidence.
2. What are good AI visibility tools under $50 per month for a small business? Distinguish a one-off answer review from recurring multi-engine analytics.Discovery — does not name BotView · two runs
Run 1
Review note: BotView is absent. Every recommendation comes from two third-party roundups (robotvisible.com and getairefs.com); neither page mentioned BotView when we checked on October 12. The AthenaHQ and RankScale details are not verified here.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Run 2
Review note: BotView is absent. Same two roundup sources as run 1, neither of which lists BotView. Otterly's engine count (four included, others as add-ons) is now stated correctly. Other vendor prices are not verified here.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
3. Which free tools can evaluate whether AI crawlers can access and read my website, and what paid options add company mentions and citation analysis?Discovery — does not name BotView · two runs
Run 1
Review note: BotView is absent. The answer cites seven single-purpose free checker homepages. The paid part recommends SpyFu and Bright Data, which are SEO and data-collection tools, not company-mention or citation analysis.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
- CheckMy.site — Free AI Website Scanner | 158 Real Checks
- AI Crawlability Checker — Test If AI Bots Read Your Site
- AI Crawler Access Report: Free AI Access Check | Citant.ai
- AI Visibility Checker: Free AI Readiness and Crawler Check
- Free AI Crawler Audit Tool — Check if AI Bots Can Read Your Site | Siftly
- CrawlerCheck: Free Googlebot & AI Crawlability Test
- Free AI Visibility Scan | Can AI Crawlers Read Your Site? | Atomic Glue
- SpyFu SEO tools review
- Bright Data review
Run 2
Review note: BotView is absent. Same seven checker pages and the same off-topic paid suggestions as run 1.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
- CheckMy.site — Free AI Website Scanner | 158 Real Checks
- AI Crawlability Checker — Test If AI Bots Read Your Site
- AI Crawler Access Report: Free AI Access Check | Citant.ai
- AI Visibility Checker: Free AI Readiness and Crawler Check
- Free AI Crawler Audit Tool — Check if AI Bots Can Read Your Site | Siftly
- CrawlerCheck: Free Googlebot & AI Crawlability Test
- Free AI Visibility Scan | Can AI Crawlers Read Your Site? | Atomic Glue
- SpyFu SEO tools review
- Bright Data review
4. What does BotView at botview.app offer for AEO and GEO reviews? Verify its current free, Pro and Agency prices, AI answer allowances and analytics limitations.Branded — explicitly names BotView · two runs
Run 1
Review note: Correct on Pro, Agency and how checks are counted, citing our own pages. The Free plan has 20 crawler scans a month, not 3; the answer repeats our pricing from before September 23. It says limitations are not documented; our comparison pages do list them.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
- Free AEO & GEO Evaluation | AI Answer Reviews from $9 — BotView
- AI Answer Checker: Brand Mentions & Citations | BotView
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- AI Answer Checker: Brand Mentions & Citations | BotView
Run 2
Review note: Correct on Pro, Agency, check accounting and limitations (no automatic monitoring, multi-engine share of voice or consumer ChatGPT rankings). The Free plan has 20 crawler scans a month, not 3; the answer repeats our pricing from before September 23.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
- Free AEO & GEO Evaluation | AI Answer Reviews from $9 — BotView
- AI Answer Checker: Brand Mentions & Citations | BotView
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- Best AEO & GEO Tools (2026): 5 Options Compared | BotView
5. Compare BotView at botview.app with OtterlyAI for a UK small business choosing an affordable AI visibility tool. Explain price, answer allowance, cadence, engine coverage and which use case fits each.Branded — explicitly names BotView · two runs
Run 1
Review note: No sources were cited, so the BotView match is marked uncertain. Otterly's engine coverage is now correct. The Free plan has 20 crawler scans a month, not 3; the answer repeats our pricing from before September 23. Otterly's Standard and Premium prices are not verified here.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
A matching name appears, but the answer does not clearly identify your business. Review the original evidence.
No sources cited.
Run 2
Review note: Cites both pricing pages; Otterly's engine coverage is correct. The Free plan has 20 crawler scans a month, not 3; the answer repeats our pricing from before September 23. The answer ends mid-sentence at the output limit.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- OtterlyAI Pricing - Transparent & Simple
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- OtterlyAI Pricing - Transparent & Simple
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- OtterlyAI Pricing - Transparent & Simple
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- OtterlyAI Pricing - Transparent & Simple
- AI Answer Checker: Brand Mentions & Citations | BotView
September 8: the first 10 answers and corrections
What needed correcting
- Both pricing answers incorrectly gave the Free plan three AI answer checks. Free includes zero AI answer checks; crawler scans are a separate allowance. Current plans.
- One comparison claimed BotView monitors answers across engines. Paid answers use OpenAI only; crawler access checks cover multiple bots.
- Both budget answers claimed OtterlyAI Lite includes seven engines. Its pricing page listed four, with others as add-ons.
- Some sources were unrelated to the adjacent recommendation. One answer mixed human accessibility checks with crawler checks; another ended mid-bullet. A completed request is not a quality guarantee.
GEO means Generative Engine Optimization; two answers expanded it incorrectly. Other third-party claims in the raw answers remain unverified.
1. Which affordable AEO or GEO tools should a UK small business consider for reviewing its website and checking AI answers? Compare entry prices, included checks and limitations.Discovery — does not name BotView · two runs
Run 1
Review note: The answer mixes subscription tools with costly services. Citation titles include a casino app and an unrelated event exhibitor; those titles do not substantiate the adjacent AEO recommendations. BotView is absent. We did not validate every competitor claim.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
- Analyzing Brand Visibility on AI Search Platforms: Otterly.AI - WediaCorp
- Best AEO Tools for Ecommerce in 2026 (Honest Comparison) - Ecommerce Paradise – Build & Scale High-Ticket Ecommerce Businesses
- Livescore Casino App: Download & Play In Minutes
- Pricing: £99/month, expert from £1,495 | AEOscore UK
- Arex - NCT Events
- How AEO-REX Works · Answer Engine Optimisation for UK SMEs | AEO-REX
- Elmo vs Goodie | AI Visibility Tool Comparison · Elmo
- AEO tools comparison (2026): honest pros and cons | monitoraeo
- AEO marketing agency: Unlock Big Answers 2025
- AEO Pricing, Published Rates, No Discovery Call Required | Question.Marketing
Run 2
Review note: The same unrelated casino and event citations recur. The answer also ends with an unfinished bullet; the product returned it as complete. BotView is absent. Do not treat the tool list as verified advice.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
- Analyzing Brand Visibility on AI Search Platforms: Otterly.AI - WediaCorp
- RockCheck — Tested GEO & AEO Tools for Small Agencies
- Livescore Casino App: Download & Play In Minutes
- Pricing: £99/month, expert from £1,495 | AEOscore UK
- Arex - NCT Events
- How AEO-REX Works · Answer Engine Optimisation for UK SMEs | AEO-REX
- Learnosity Acquires Questionmark to Accelerate Expansion Into Fast-Growing Learning and Development Market
- AEO Pricing, Published Rates, No Discovery Call Required | Question.Marketing
- 15 Best Goodie Alternatives & Competitors in 2026
- AEO tools comparison (2026): honest pros and cons | monitoraeo
2. What are good AI visibility tools under $50 per month for a small business? Distinguish a one-off answer review from recurring multi-engine analytics.Discovery — does not name BotView · two runs
Run 1
Review note: The claim that OtterlyAI Lite includes seven engines conflicts with its pricing page: four are included and other engines are add-ons. BotView is absent. Other vendor prices in this raw answer have not been independently verified here.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
Run 2
Review note: The seven-engine Lite claim repeats. OtterlyAI’s current pricing page lists four included engines. BotView is absent. The added research citation does not verify the tool prices.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
- Best AI Visibility Tools Under $50 (2026)
- Best AI SEO Tracking Tools Under $50/Month (2026)
- Best AI Visibility Tools for Small Businesses and Startups | AI Radar
- Best AI Visibility Tools Under $50 (2026)
- How to choose an AI visibility tool · Robot Visible
- Don't Measure Once: Measuring Visibility in AI Search (GEO)
3. Which free tools can evaluate whether AI crawlers can access and read my website, and what paid options add company mentions and citation analysis?Discovery — does not name BotView · two runs
Run 1
Review note: This answer mixes AI crawler checks with human accessibility tools (WCAG/ADA). These are different tests. BotView is absent. We have not tested or endorsed the listed tools.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
- Free AI Crawler Audit Tool — Check if AI Bots Can Read Your Site | Siftly
- AccessScan — Free Website Accessibility Checker (WCAG & EAA)
- Website Accessibility Checker — Free Online WCAG & ADA Scanner
- MentionPop — AEO & GEO Analytics Platform
- Outreachify — Get Your Brand Mentioned by AI
- Clearscope review: A well-rounded SEO optimization tool for business use
- MarketMuse review: Businesses of all sizes should consider this SEO optimization tool
Run 2
Review note: The selected tools differ from the first run, but BotView is still absent. Source presence does not verify the claimed features. We have not independently tested this list.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
- CrawlCheck — AI visibility audit: what AI crawlers actually receive
- AI Crawler Access Report: Free AI Access Check | Citant.ai
- Free AI Crawler Audit Tool — Check if AI Bots Can Read Your Site | Siftly
- IndexDoctor.io, Free SEO and AI Visibility Diagnostics
- CheckMy.site — Free AI Website Scanner | 158 Real Checks
- AI Crawlability Checker — Test If AI Bots Read Your Site
- SpyFu SEO tools review
4. What does BotView at botview.app offer for AEO and GEO reviews? Verify its current free, Pro and Agency prices, AI answer allowances and analytics limitations.Branded — explicitly names BotView · two runs
Run 1
Review note: The paid prices and answer allowances match BotView pricing. Two claims are wrong: GEO means Generative Engine Optimization, and the Free plan includes zero AI answer checks (three crawler scans). A diagnostic cannot ensure indexing or representation in AI answers.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
- What is AEO? Answer Engine Optimization Explained | BotView
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- Pricing - BotView | AI Answer Reports & Crawler Checks
- BotView - See What Google & AI Crawlers Actually See
Run 2
Review note: The same GEO expansion and free-answer allowance errors recur despite citations to BotView pricing. Free includes zero AI answer checks. The indexing assurance is unsupported; the actual product observes access and selected answers.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
5. Compare BotView at botview.app with OtterlyAI for a UK small business choosing an affordable AI visibility tool. Explain price, answer allowance, cadence, engine coverage and which use case fits each.Branded — explicitly names BotView · two runs
Run 1
Review note: The answer names BotView but supplies no citation annotations. The product therefore marks the business match uncertain. Its cadence paragraph describes crawler scans; paid AI answers are run manually. This is not independently sourced proof of recommendation quality.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
A matching name appears, but the answer does not clearly identify your business. Review the original evidence.
No sources cited.
Run 2
Review note: The answer cites BotView and OtterlyAI, but wrongly claims BotView monitors answers from multiple engines. BotView runs OpenAI API answers only; its multi-crawler checks are a separate feature. GBP conversions were generated by the model and are not our prices.
Original model output below. Includes errors; not verified buying advice.
Sources supplied with this answer
Method and downloadable evidence
Captured 2026-09-08T21:27:25.875Z–2026-09-08T21:28:45.281Z and 2026-10-12T19:36:47.780Z–2026-10-12T19:37:29.772Z. One subject, five authored questions (three discovery, two branded), two runs per question each time. September used the staging assessment and rerun workflow; October used a direct API script with the same request configuration.
Model: gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14. English, approximate location GB; required web search, low context, at most one tool call, 800 output tokens, no automatic provider retries. Each request starts a fresh answer context. A name without a link to botview.app counts as named but uncertain.
On October 12 we fetched the cited third-party roundups and checker pages and searched them for “BotView”; none mentioned it. Repetition does not guarantee the same result, and ten answers per date do not represent other models or longer-term visibility. All results are included. Review was assisted by an AI coding agent; no independent human sign-off is claimed.
October answers and method (JSON)September answers and method (JSON)